This is a blog post that’s been brewing in my head for some time, and a few recent events brought the thoughts to the surface again. It’s not incredibly well-thought out, nor is it based on hours of biblical study, but I’d be interested in your opinions.
As human beings, we have a deep desire, or perhaps even need, for things to make sense. We would like the universe, and our lives, to proceed in a well-ordered, reasonable, sensible fashion. We would like the laws of cause and effect to behave in the way we’d expect them to: i.e., put this amount of effort/good behaviour in, get this favourable result; do this bad thing or fail to put in this effort, get this unpleasant result.
We’d like our relationship with God to proceed in the same way. Do the right things, life will go well. Put in x amount of prayer and Bible study, grow x amount in our intimacy with God and holiness. Live according to the “rules”, and reap prosperity/good relationships/nice jobs/well-behaved children/smooth sailing/immunity from problems.
Most of us would not put these feelings into words, but it’s a deep-seated part of who we are nonetheless. It appeals to our innate sense of justice. It’s why we’re so jarred when things don’t seem to “make sense”: good, righteous people suffer terribly; you hear a calling from God that does not come to pass though years go by; you receive a clear prophecy which comes to pass and then the results of it don’t seem good; evil, unscrupulous people enjoy happy, prosperous, relatively easy and pain-free lives. And on and on.
It’s an ancient conundrum, expressed in book form in Job, as well as in many of the Psalms. It’s a conundrum I’ve puzzled over again and again, as crushing disappointments roll in on a regular basis and the things I’ve thought would come to pass in my life don’t seem to.
The thing is, the Old Covenant seems to have worked that way. God gave Israel the law, and then promised blessings for obedience and curses for disobedience. The blessings included agricultural prosperity, children, defeat of Israel’s enemies, establishment in the land, and physical health and wealth. The curses were the opposite. (See Deuteronomy 28).
When you come to the New Covenant, rather than these promises being amped up, they disappear. Jesus promised trouble and suffering. He said his followers would be hated as he was hated. Greater godliness and calling seems to lead to greater suffering, as exemplified by the apostles. On a smaller scale, godliness and devotion to Jesus in our personal lives doesn’t guarantee exemption from suffering and poverty, or even life making any kind of sense at all. Most of us can testify to that from our own experience.
The longer I live and the more of life’s pain I experience, the more convinced I am that God really isn’t interested in our lives “making sense”, or even in us understanding what is going on. I believe what he’s interested in is the faith that will pursue him and worship him in spite of pain, that faces life’s idiosyncrasies and outright injustices and says, “You are my only hope.” God doesn’t want a fair-weather faith or fair-weather followers who tread on his heels for the material goodies he hands out, like the crowd did to Jesus after he multiplied the bread (John 6). Rather, he wants those who will stick with him when he tells us hard things like “Eat my flesh” and promises us suffering. He wants those who love him, not his ability to make our lives easier.
I don’t think we’re guaranteed, or indeed even likely, to be able to figure out the vagaries of life and our circumstances. Rather, I think we are called to allow them to be goads to drive us to pursue God, a deeper knowledge of him, greater intimacy with him, better understanding of his will for us, and a stronger commitment to follow him, no matter what. After all, it’s his love for us that can and will triumph over even the most horrible of circumstances (Romans 8:28-39), and it’s a reality that we can experience no matter what we are going through.